Reptile Forum, Reptile Classifieds - CaptiveBred Forum Index Reptile Forum, Reptile Classifieds - CaptiveBred
A site to share your Reptile experiances & ask questions
 
 FAQFAQ   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups   RegisterRegister 
 ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   Log inLog in 

How NOT to handle a grass snake
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4
 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Reptile Forum, Reptile Classifieds - CaptiveBred Forum Index -> Reptiles in the field
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
slangman
I've settled in...


Joined: 03 May 2007
Posts: 36
Location: liverpool

PostPosted: Tue Jun 10, 2008 11:23 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

i for one havent seen a grass snake in the uk but dont really see what the fuss is about . Excuse my ignorince but i have seen a lot worse than 'tailing' a grass snake and think that maybe you are simply making a mountain out of a mole hill . Sure the snake is not happy but the alternative is to restrain it with hook sticks? i have seen many a snake get more damaged by these impliments thatn by being tailed close to the ground . I dont know this chap so am not on his side , its just that the snake is a coloubrid and when it is released , doesnt apear to be in that much distress . If it were a python and could suffer from being tailed then fine but its not and i think for the benifit of the vid , it is probably the best option. I have seen people(well respected people ) like steve irwin and austin stevens and your very own Mark o shea , all tailing snakes and not a peap was mentioned .
just my opinion but if ya wanna bite back , feel free . I am big and can take it LOL .
PS i aint saying i agree with everyone going otu and making you tube vids of them all doing the same thing but for educational purposes , i found the vid interesting and cant see what all the fuss was about . If he tried to handle the snake with hooks etc , it would certainly suffered more seing as how frisky it was .
_________________
African House Snakes .....
http://lamprophis.proboards62.com/
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website MSN Messenger
benwaddams
I'm new here...


Joined: 09 Jun 2008
Posts: 2
Location: Buckinghamshire, England

PostPosted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 12:44 am    Post subject: I guess the subject is...Ben Waddams Reply with quote

Hiya Guys,

I have read all the comments posted on here. I would first like to thank you, not for simply spending the time viewing my clips (whatever you made of them) but for getting involved, taking time out and discussing them (positive or negative). I am really encouraged that there are so many caring and concerned people out there and far from upsetting me, this forum has really made me feel a great deal happier about our herpers and animal lovers.

I don't intend to sit (or fall off) the fence, and I will defend my views and will try and answer as many points, queries and questions as I can.

First off, I can absolutely assure everyone that I am not an attention grabber/seeker or whatever. I believe my first video was that of my diving in the local river. This was entirely a bit of fun when it was hot enough to do that with a mate and a couple of dogs. Of course there was no snake there and if there had been I would certainly have let him/her swim off rather than being stupid enough to risk damaging it. I am really not in need of youtube as a platform to show off on, I don't need the attention and I don't want it. I am simply doing it to showcase our wildlife in an interesting and unique way and if I ride the wave of my own enthusiasm, I'm sorry, but that's really what I am like - take it or leave it and apologies to anyone who doesn't like it.

I am not trying to copy Steve Irwin (oh and by the way, I have worked with Austin Stevens at Tigress Productions and consider him to be one of the very worst 'wildlife presenters' (or is that actor?) out there). On the other hand, I had immense respect for Steve Irwin. I believe his message about not sitting back on the long lens and merely observing wildlife, but getting right in there and dragging you in with him, up close and personal with the animals was a revelation and highly highly successful in (as he would say it) getting people jazzed up about wildlife and each species' conservation and preservation. I think if people get involved with wildlife on that level, for that reason and with that eventual aim in mind, they will be doing alot of good on this planet.

Here I'd like to admit to some mistakes. I absolutely agree that I should have put a warning and/or statement of some description up before and after my clips and if I make any in the future, this is what I will improve on. I AM concerned that people will try and copy (I hope I don't come across as arrogant enough to use the term 'imitate') me and injure the animal concerned or heaven forbid (!) themselves. I would love for viewers to go out there and try and find the species I show, but certainly not damage or unnecessarily disturb them in any way because of it (adult female adders for example in april/may/june when they can become stressed and reabsorb their embryos). This is something I will address in future clips and I sincerely thank you for your comments.

My Vipera Berus info was off a little. I don't really have an excuse for this one. I have admitted to it in the comments if people can be bothered to read them and all I will say is a) it was my first adder at that location and my first youngster and I was literally, lost for words - hence the post commentary, and I also felt I was stressing the little girl out and so the clip is actually, as I'm sure you noticed, the same shot several times, repeated/flipped/reversed/flopped/zoomed, because after about 15 seconds I let her go! Apologies...as I say, its in my reply to the comments and b) Thank you for the info concerning hedgehogs and birds of prey/corvids.

Alot of my negative comments concern...concern for the animals, which is why it makes me so happy that people care. I can, hand on heart assure you that none of the animals I've found on my walks with a camera were harmed in any way. It would never enter my head to treat an animal with any less respect than my friends, which I consider them to be. I considered that Grass Snake to be happier being tailed than being held around the body or (seriously..heaven forbid) around the neck or head. I would never touch a reptile's head or neck and all of my captures are held as gently as possible. For 95% of the Grass Snake video, although I was in contact with the tail, he was given support on the ground or my other hand and I was simply keeping in contact with him.

I see it like this (and this goes for the Grass Snake, the Adder, the Gopher Snake, the Rattler, the Red Rumped Tarantula and everything else) if I get bitten, I look like an idiot...which wouldn't bother me personally, but if I was say a taxi driver and you got in and I said 'yer hop on inside mate, I've had 43 crashes so far, lets see what happens this time...' would you think I knew what I was doing? Probably not! I think 'dodging' a bite by watching an animal's mood and knowing what he or she is thinking, (which can only be said, I believe, with respect, if you have had alot of experience with the species) is far more impressive and demonstrates a much greater understanding and therefore respect for the animal concerned, than getting bitten and watching the blood ooz out and giving the animal a bad reputation. Again, just my own personal opinion. (and mate, there's a big difference between a fast reaction time and 'flinching')

I was until recently a 'hot house' keeper at my local zoo and, although no-one seems to be questioning my experience, I just wanted to take the opportunity to let people know that I am fairly well qualified as a safe herp handler, having been in contact with some great stuff! Saw-scaled vipers, burmeses, emerald boas, alot of scorps and tarantulas, sailfins, crocs, matamatas, snappers, rattlers, house snakes, terrapins, snake necked turtles, basilisks, plateds etc the list is almost endless...does this prepare me or qualify my to pick up or touch wild species, certainly not. But I think it gives me a degree more respect, knowledge and practical understanding of SOME of them. (can a large rattlesnake reach my chin within this range or not...for example!)

I see myself as a familiar animal (that being a human being) for others of my species to use as a link between them and the wildlife I am showing.

As far as 'wild' jobs and practical experience goes, please ask me for it if you disbelieve me, but to list a few: Slow worm conservation project for Cardiff Uni, Sand Lizard and Smooth Snake habitat surveying for Dorset wildlife trust, RSPCA worker on the Napoli sea bird disaster, Water Vole researcher on the Grand Union canal, Amphibian swabbing for protection against the viral pandemic...Slightly further a-field, I have been involved with GAFI, the Great Apes Film Initiative, which uses innovative ideas and award winning documentary films as outreach material, travelling to areas such as Borneo and the Democratic Republic of Congo, and showing these films (ie the BBC's Cousins) to the local people who have to live in the presence of these apes as well as to the government ministers, responsible for the civil wars or deforestation that are so devastating to these creatures.

So to sum up. Thank you. I admit some mistakes and yes, we do all make them. What you see in my clips, is what you get. I'm not acting, or I'd be somewhere else right now. I have grown up with and handled dozens, if not hundreds of reptiles and consider myself to have at least a bit of experience with them and other reptiles. (I go on walks to my favourite herping grounds most weekends and rarely touch or pick up what I see). I am content with a photo most of the time but, and if I have a statement, I guess this is it;

To merely view, observe and pass by wildlife that is in decline around the world and across the UK would be selfish. Why? Because one can do so much more. You can go and find and handle and touch and smell our wildlife (drawing the line at adders) and I believe if people don't, then we are going to start seeing extinct species very, very soon. If the current approach is not working as well as it probably should, why not try something a little different and unique? Alot of these people that really experience wildlife hands-on (not wrestling with them for heaven's sake, but gently) and get involved, go on to become conservation officers, environmental ministers, biology teachers and conservationists to name but a few. Keeping it local...British wildlife, especially our herps, aren't going extinct because people are taking photos and vision of them and experiencing them...they are becoming extinct because of our greed. Our farming culture and our insaitable appetite for houses. If I can excite one person and make them care about our wildlife, just that one extra degree which means they take a conservation themed career, then I will be forever a happy person.

I hope I have answered some of your questions. I have my own views, just as you have yours. I won't get drawn into a slogging match but I would like to reply to sensible comments and replies of your own. Sorry for upsetting anyone and apologies if my spelling's a bit off here and there, I did a zoology, geography and conservation degree with wildlife art thrown in, not english.

Thank you for doing what you do, as you know, our wildlife needs our help and our love more now than at any other time.

Happy herping, cheers,

Ben
_________________
Ben Waddams
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
Peter Parrot
Site Moderator


Joined: 15 Jan 2006
Posts: 5402
Location: Over the bridge

PostPosted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 1:18 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

slangman wrote:
i for one havent seen a grass snake in the uk but dont really see what the fuss is about . If he tried to handle the snake with hooks etc , it would certainly suffered more seing as how frisky it was .


The reason that the grass snake in the video was so frisky was because of the discomfort of being suspended by the tip of it`s tail. I have encountered grass snakes on countless occasions and can count on one hand how many were as frisky as the one in Ben`s video. All of these calmed down within minutes to wrap themselves around my hand.

I don`t know of anyone using snake hooks on non venomous snakes of any kind (EDIT: In the British Isles). It certainly would be a ridiculous and unnecessary thing to do.

As is tailing a harmless snake.

It is not the way to handle an animal, leaving it dangle off the ground for periods of time with no support.

I caught a female grass snake today as it happens. She was an individual that I have encountered previously and was in the middle of her shed cycle with very milky eyes, a time when snakes are at their most vulnerable and defensive. She wrapped herself around my hand almost immediately. I was able to collect a sample from her as she musked, and then put the lid on the sample tube, all with the snake in or rather around my other hand. I wasn`t bitten either, and I didn`t swing her around by her tail.

Members of the public should not be encouraged to tail harmless grass snakes or adders for that matter! If you look at the famous TV snake handlers that have been referred to previously, when a snake is tailed, the weight of the animal is still supported either by a stick or the ground. and not left dangling for periods of time. Tailing a grass snake is competely and wholly unecessary as it would be to use a snake hook.

Here are some images of wild grass snakes taken seconds after capture. No dangling by the tail, and absolutely no snake hooks! Laughing






Ben,

Thank you for taking the time to reply.

benwaddams wrote:


First off, I can absolutely assure everyone that I am not an attention grabber/seeker or whatever. I believe my first video was that of my diving in the local river. This was entirely a bit of fun when it was hot enough to do that with a mate and a couple of dogs.


I did think it was funny.

benwaddums wrote:
(oh and by the way, I have worked with Austin Stevens at Tigress Productions and consider him to be one of the very worst 'wildlife presenters' (or is that actor?) out there).


I would never have guessed! We agree on Austin Stevens at least. Wink

benwaddums wrote:
Here I'd like to admit to some mistakes. I absolutely agree that I should have put a warning and/or statement of some description up before and after my clips and if I make any in the future, this is what I will improve on. I AM concerned that people will try and copy (I hope I don't come across as arrogant enough to use the term 'imitate') me and injure the animal concerned or heaven forbid (!) themselves. I would love for viewers to go out there and try and find the species I show, but certainly not damage or unnecessarily disturb them in any way because of it (adult female adders for example in april/may/june when they can become stressed and reabsorb their embryos). This is something I will address in future clips and I sincerely thank you for your comments.


Fair play. Cool


benwaddums wrote:
Alot of my negative comments concern...concern for the animals, which is why it makes me so happy that people care. I can, hand on heart assure you that none of the animals I've found on my walks with a camera were harmed in any way. It would never enter my head to treat an animal with any less respect than my friends, which I consider them to be. I considered that Grass Snake to be happier being tailed than being held around the body or (seriously..heaven forbid) around the neck or head. I would never touch a reptile's head or neck and all of my captures are held as gently as possible. For 95% of the Grass Snake video, although I was in contact with the tail, he was given support on the ground or my other hand and I was simply keeping in contact with him.


Ben, having caught more grass snakes than I care to remember over the past 30 plus years, the only time that it is neccessary to grab the animal is during the initial capture, after which the snake entwines itself around my hand. It holds me, I don`t hold it.

benwaddums wrote:
If I can excite one person and make them care about our wildlife, just that one extra degree which means they take a conservation themed career, then I will be forever a happy person.


Fair comment also. I would be a great deal happier if you reshot the grass snake episode without all the unnecessary tailing however. Hopefully that will reduce the instances of copy cat behaviour which may be less "careful" then you were. A few warnings regarding adders wouldn`t go amiss either. Wink

EDIT. Ben if you have the time, you may want to read the thread here; http://www.herpetofauna.co.uk/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=2585&PN=1&TPN=1

Some of the most experienced British field herpetologist`s are members of this forum, many of which have already commented on your videos. I am sure that they would be only too happy to discuss your videos with you and advise you regarding handling techniques.
_________________
YSBRYDOLI POBL, GWELLA LLEOEDD
INSPIRING PEOPLE, IMPROVING PLACES
www.btcv.org
Visit our website - Gwelwch ein Gwefan
www.btcvcymru.org
Llinell Gymorth / Helpline: 08702 40 48 41


Last edited by Peter Parrot on Wed Jun 11, 2008 2:29 pm; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
benwaddams
I'm new here...


Joined: 09 Jun 2008
Posts: 2
Location: Buckinghamshire, England

PostPosted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 12:18 pm    Post subject: Ben Waddams Reply with quote

Hi Peter,

Thanks for replying. And thank you also for the great pictures. I intended my reply to apply to all the comments on my clips, not just to you, so please don't take things personally.

I admit that it would have been much nicer to let her hold on and wrap around my fingers and as you say, this happens most of the time with any Grass snakes that I pick up. On the other hand, this particular individual was rather grumpy (during the 10 seconds after capture and before filming) and I have aired my views about getting bitten. She was supported for 95% of the time with either here lower third or most of her body on the ground or in my hand. But yes, in retrospect, it would have been better not to tail her.

What I would like to do, concerning future clips, is what you say, show how gentle these beautiful reptiles are and try and educate people further about them. But I hand on heart believe that particular animal was worked up about something before. That's all I will say on that clip.

Thank you very much again for taking the time to reply to me and point me in the right direction, and again for the photos, great stuff!

Cheers,

Ben
_________________
Ben Waddams
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
Scott W
Site Admin


Joined: 15 Apr 2004
Posts: 13355
Location: London, England.

PostPosted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 12:31 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hi Ben, thanks for joining and responding to peoples concerns / comments.

Personally I don't think you did any harm to any of the animals involved but I would be concerned with the many copy cats out there that haven't a clue and in all likely-hood will harm the snakes during capture and worse perhaps when they git bit actually retaliate at the snake.

I must say that at the time Irwin was great and overall the positive far exceeded the negative with his actual methods BUT I think those days are gone now and a new type of interaction with wildlife is needed, YES I'm all for showing wild animals close up and that they are not aggressive when not provoked but it does need to be done without the 'drama' of many of the current 'Irwin imitators' on youtube (not just your clips).

best regards
Scott
_________________

Please DO NOT pm orders for reptiles, send email instead scott@captivebred.co.uk
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Peter Parrot
Site Moderator


Joined: 15 Jan 2006
Posts: 5402
Location: Over the bridge

PostPosted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 1:31 pm    Post subject: Re: Ben Waddams Reply with quote

benwaddams wrote:
Hi Peter,

Thanks for replying. And thank you also for the great pictures. I intended my reply to apply to all the comments on my clips, not just to you, so please don't take things personally.


No personal offence taken. Cool

benwaddums wrote:
I admit that it would have been much nicer to let her hold on and wrap around my fingers and as you say, this happens most of the time with any Grass snakes that I pick up. On the other hand, this particular individual was rather grumpy (during the 10 seconds after capture and before filming)


This is where we disagree. The grass snake in the video did calm down at one point, when you allowed it to rest it`s weight in your hand. Had you just released your grip on it`s tail at that point and allowed it to run through your hands it would have remained calm. It was at this point that you again suspended it from it`s tail before releasing it. Absolutely no need to at all. The grass snake that I captured and took a sample from yesterday was in shed as I mentioned previously and exceedingly grumpy. She was held in the same manner as the animals in the images that I posted earlier.

benwaddums wrote:
and I have aired my views about getting bitten.


This also baffles me. I apologize for repeating myself but after handling well over two thousand grass snakes, (only one of which was tailed, explained forthwith) I have not been bitten once. Occasionally a particularly disgruntled animal will bluff a "strike" in an attempt to escape. The fact that these few individuals do not even open their mouths however makes me confident that a bite will not be the end result. I may be covered in musk on occasion yes, but bitten, not once yet. Infact I know of only one individual out of many that have handled a good deal more animals than I have that has ever received a bite. In the case of grass snakes, I really feel that there is little or no argument that it is neccessary to guard against grass snakes biting. If you were talking about smooth snakes (the bite is superficial to say the least) and adders then I would agree that there is a case. I still would not tail a smooth snake.

ben waddums wrote:
But yes, in retrospect, it would have been better not to tail her.


Thank you.

benwaddums wrote:
What I would like to do, concerning future clips, is what you say, show how gentle these beautiful reptiles are and try and educate people further about them.


Glad to hear it.

benwaddums wrote:
But I hand on heart believe that particular animal was worked up about something before.


Sorry Ben but the animal did calm down in your hand as I mentioned previously. The snake would then have happily wound around your fingers, but was unable to due to the fact that your other hand was still restraining the animal by the tip of it`s tail. This is the snakes anchor, and it`s security. Had you at this point released it`s tail and allowed the animal to trickle through your hands, all would have been nice and calm, and subject to there being no sudden movements in the animal`s vacinity (waving hands for example) there would have been no bluff striking. The fact that you maintained your grip on the end of it`s tail, and then lifted it again unsupported prior to release understandably riled it up once more. This is purely constructive criticism (after admittedly being initially very annoyed at the sight of the grass snake tailed and unsupported) from someone with a little more experience than you regarding grass snakes. If my experience is not enough for you then there are people far more qualified who would also like to discuss that particular clip who can be contacted via the link provided by me in the last post.

benwaddums wrote:
That's all I will say on that clip.


Will you at least consider removing that particular one, as well as perhaps reposting a video which does not depict grass snakes being tailed for young people to emulate? Editing the adder clips with a warning would also be nice to see. Smile Smile

benwaddums wrote:
Thank you very much again for taking the time to reply to me and point me in the right direction, and again for the photos, great stuff!


Thank you for the kind words. Smile

Scott W wrote:


Personally I don't think you did any harm to any of the animals involved but I would be concerned with the many copy cats out there that haven't a clue and in all likely-hood will harm the snakes during capture and worse perhaps when they git bit actually retaliate at the snake.
YES I'm all for showing wild animals close up and that they are not aggressive when not provoked but it does need to be done without the 'drama' of many of the current 'Irwin imitators' on youtube (not just your clips).

best regards
Scott


I couldn`t have put it better myself. Cool



Ben, I sympathise with your enthusiasm. I also must mention, my very first grass snake experience was at the age of 8. Having been obsessed with our British reptiles and amphibians since very early childhood, I had read all material available countless times (the new naturalist`s series first edition of British Reptiles and Amphibians by Malcolm Smith was my bible as a child) as well as constantly bombarding anyone with countless questions pertaining to herpetology whether they were remotely interested or not. Thus I knew what to expect when I saw my first grass snake (the evil smelling musk etc). My first sighting was literally the last 12"of an animal dissappearing into a canal. You can imagine what I did. Confident by the markings that it was indeed a grass snake and not an adder, I grabbed the only available part of the animal, it`s tail. Partly due to sheer joy at having discovered my first grass snake, and partly due to my inexperience and hence slight initial wariness of the animal, I allowed the snake to dangle whilst I held it`s tail (which also causes me to think that you may have not encountered many grass snakes in the field as I do not believe that you would have been as wary as you were in the video had you more experience of the ways of grass snakes upon capture. Should this be the case, then it is nothing to be ashamed of,and there are plenty of experienced people who would be glad to advise you regarding the handling of grass snakes). Like you with the adder, I stood there mesmorised for a few seconds whilst the poor creature dangled and musked. Then the animal opened it`s mouth, and regurgitated a small common frog, which amazingly promptly hopped off into the canal (one lucky frog). There then followed two smooth newts which weren`t so fortunate. This alone is a demonstration of the level of potential stress that can be caused by the act of tailing a grass snake, and another good reason not to do so. Needless to say that I have not tailed a single grass snake since then, over 30 years ago.

I shall take this opportunity to welcome you to the forum, I hope that you find it as useful as I have done. Wink I would also like to both apologize for perhaps failing to conceal my initial annoyance upon viewing the video, and to commend you on your mature attitude towards the criticisms that have been put to you. I shall quote another person`s words regarding your grass snake video (from the RAUK forum). I happen to think that his summary assessment of your grass snake video is very well worded;

Quote;

Re Mr. YouTube...half of me thinks 'bless him, at least he's keen'
the other half thinks maybe he needs a little more time, experience and training before using such an influential medium.
__________________
Steve Langham - Reptiles Officer
Surrey Amphibian & Reptile Group (SARG).

_________________
YSBRYDOLI POBL, GWELLA LLEOEDD
INSPIRING PEOPLE, IMPROVING PLACES
www.btcv.org
Visit our website - Gwelwch ein Gwefan
www.btcvcymru.org
Llinell Gymorth / Helpline: 08702 40 48 41
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Reptile Forum, Reptile Classifieds - CaptiveBred Forum Index -> Reptiles in the field All times are GMT + 2 Hours
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4
Page 4 of 4

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group